MLB Sports Card Catalog 9/13 - 9/17
Updated September 21, 2026
This auction ended on September 17, 2026.
See upcoming auctions from Consign Online LLC
or auctions happening this week.
| Date | September 17, 2026 at 8:00 PM EDT |
| Type | Online only |
| Auction house | Consign Online LLC |
| Location | Effingham, Illinois, 62401 · more auctions in Effingham |
| Lots | 1088 |
What's in this auction
1088 lots, mostly sports & trading cards (1070). 1088 lots have photos and 1088 have full descriptions. Bidding is online through the auction house's catalog.
From the auction house
Upcoming auction: MLB Sports Card Catalog 9/13 - 9/17. Full catalog and bidding: view on hibid .
In this auction (1088 lots)
Categories: Sports & Trading Cards (1070)
- Lot 13255 — Adrian Del Castillo Baseball Card Rookie Arizona
- Lot 13254 — Adrian Del Castillo Baseball Card Rookie Arizona
- Lot 14154 — Brandon Webb Baseball Card 0189/2003 Arizona Diam
- Lot 14134 — Brandon Webb Baseball Card Arizona Diamondbacks
- Lot 13374 — Corbin Carroll Baseball Card Rookie Arizona Diamo
- Lot 13373 — Corbin Carroll Baseball Card Rookie Arizona Diamo
- Lot 13371 — Corbin Carroll Baseball Card Insert Arizona Diamon
- Lot 13372 — Corbin Carroll Baseball Card Arizona Diamondbacks
- Lot 14383 — Corbin Carroll Baseball Card Arizona Diamondbacks
- Lot 14455 — Corbin Carroll Baseball Card Insert Arizona Diamon
- Lot 13377 — Cristian Mena Baseball Card Rookie Arizona Diamon
- Lot 13378 — Cristian Mena Baseball Card Rookie Arizona Diamon
- Lot 14659 — Curt Schilling Baseball Card Insert Arizona Diamon
- Lot 13415 — Druw Jones Baseball Card Parallel Arizona Diamondb
- Lot 13414 — Druw Jones Baseball Card Arizona Diamondbacks
- Lot 13438 — Eugenio Suarez Baseball Card Arizona Diamondbacks
- Lot 13439 — Eugenio Suarez Baseball Card Arizona Diamondbacks
- Lot 13475 — Gabriel Moreno Baseball Card Rookie Arizona Diamo
- Lot 13621 — Luis Frias Baseball Card 0187/2022 Rookie Parallel
- Lot 14868 — Randy Johnson Baseball Card Arizona Diamondbacks
- Lot 14196 — Randy Johnson Baseball Card Insert Arizona Diamond
- Lot 14224 — Randy Johnson Baseball Card Insert Arizona Diamond
- Lot 14026 — Yilber Diaz Baseball Card Rookie Arizona Diamondb
- Lot 14031 — Zac Gallen Baseball Card Arizona Diamondbacks
- Lot 14635 — Zack Godley Baseball Card Rookie Arizona Diamondb
- Lot 13256 — AJ Smith-Shawver Baseball Card Rookie Atlanta Bra
- Lot 14195 — Atlanta Braves Baseball Card Parallel Atlanta Brav
- Lot 14939 — Chipper Jones Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14707 — Chipper Jones Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14160 — Chipper Jones Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14903 — Chipper Jones Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14493 — Chipper Jones Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14230 — Chipper Jones Marcus Giles Baseball Card Atlanta
- Lot 13375 — Craig Kimbrel Baseball Card 046/325 Parallel Thick
- Lot 13382 — Dale Murphy Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 13381 — Dale Murphy Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14265 — Dave Johnson Baseball Card Vintage Atlanta Braves
- Lot 13393 — Dave Justice Baseball Card Rookie Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14377 — Deion Sanders Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 13413 — Drew Waters Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14312 — Dusty Baker Baseball Card Vintage Atlanta Braves
- Lot 13423 — Dylan Dodd Baseball Card 1930/2023 Rookie Parallel
- Lot 14198 — Greg Maddux Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14234 — Greg Maddux Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14279 — Greg Maddux Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14459 — Greg Maddux John Smoltz Baseball Card Insert Atlan
- Lot 14462 — Hank Aaron Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14678 — Hank Aaron Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14843 — Hank Aaron Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14829 — Hank Aaron Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Braves
- Lot 13505 — Hurston Waldrep Baseball Card Rookie Atlanta Brav
- Lot 14554 — John Smoltz Baseball Card Rookie Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14943 — John Smoltz Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 13630 — Marcell Ozuna Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14948 — Matt Olson Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 13673 — Nacho Alvarez Jr. Baseball Card Rookie Insert Atla
- Lot 14273 — Ozzie Albies Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 13873 — Ozzie Albies Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 13947 — Ron Gant Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14371 — Ronald Acuna Jr. Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14719 — Ronald Acuna Jr. Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Brav
- Lot 13950 — Ronald Acuna Jr. Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14602 — Ronald Acuna Jr. Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14890 — Ronald Acuna Jr. Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Brav
- Lot 13951 — Ronald Acuna Jr. Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Brav
- Lot 13973 — Steve Avery Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Braves
- Lot 13979 — Terry Pendleton Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Brave
- Lot 14772 — Tom Glavine Baseball Card Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14494 — Tom Glavine Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Braves
- Lot 14539 — Travis d'Arnaud Baseball Card Insert Atlanta Brave
- Lot 14944 — Adley Rutschman Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 14731 — Brady Anderson Baseball Card Rookie Baltimore Ori
- Lot 14245 — Brooks Robinson Mark Belanger Baseball Card Vintag
- Lot 14923 — Cade Povich Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 13327 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Insert Baltimore Orio
- Lot 13344 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 13325 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 13332 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Insert Baltimore Orio
- Lot 14292 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 13341 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 13323 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Insert Baltimore Orio
- Lot 14294 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 14771 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 13345 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 13324 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Insert Baltimore Orio
- Lot 13329 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Insert Baltimore Orio
- Lot 14535 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 14658 — Cal Ripken Jr. Baseball Card Insert Baltimore Orio
- Lot 14682 — Cedric Mullins Baseball Card Rookie Baltimore Ori
- Lot 14405 — Coby Mayo Baseball Card Rookie Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 13394 — Dave McNally Baseball Card Vintage Baltimore Oriol
- Lot 14450 — Dave McNally Baseball Card Vintage Baltimore Oriol
- Lot 14597 — Dwight Evans Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 13491 — Gunnar Henderson Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 13493 — Gunnar Henderson Baseball Card Insert Baltimore Or
- Lot 13494 — Gunnar Henderson Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 14654 — Gunnar Henderson Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 13492 — Gunnar Henderson Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 14677 — Gunnar Henderson Baseball Card Insert Baltimore Or
- Lot 14504 — Hank Bauer Dave McNally Baseball Card Vintage Balt
- Lot 13514 — Jackson Holliday Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 14873 — Jim Palmer Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 13556 — Johnny Orsino Baseball Card Vintage Baltimore Orio
- Lot 13560 — Jordan Westburg Baseball Card Rookie Baltimore Or
- Lot 14587 — Kyle Bradish Baseball Card Rookie Baltimore Oriol
- Lot 14505 — Mike Mussina Baseball Card Rookie Baltimore Oriol
- Lot 13671 — Milt Pappas Baseball Card Vintage Baltimore Oriole
- Lot 13955 — Russ Snyder Baseball Card Vintage Baltimore Oriole
- Lot 14501 — Ryan Mountcastle Baseball Card Baltimore Orioles
- Lot 14202 — Ryan Mountcastle Baseball Card Parallel Baltimore
- Lot 14247 — Brooks Robinson Baseball Card Vintage Baltimore Or
- Lot 13281 — Aroldis Chapman Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14428 — Boston Red Sox Baseball Card Vintage Boston Red So
- Lot 13311 — Brayan Bello Baseball Card Rookie Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13313 — Brayan Bello Baseball Card Rookie Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14721 — Carl Yastrzemski Baseball Card Vintage Boston Red
- Lot 14786 — Carl Yastrzemski Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14637 — Carl Yastrzemski Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14479 — Carl Yastrzemski Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14837 — Curt Schilling Baseball Card Insert Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14418 — Daisuke Matsuzaka Baseball Card Rookie Insert Bost
- Lot 14583 — David Ortiz Baseball Card Parallel Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13400 — Dennis Eckersley Baseball Card Vintage Boston Red
- Lot 13401 — Dennis Eckersley Baseball Card Vintage Boston Red
- Lot 14378 — Ellis Burks Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13476 — Garrett Crochet Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13508 — J.D. Martinez Baseball Card 161/250 Parallel Bosto
- Lot 13507 — J.D. Martinez Baseball Card Thick Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13544 — Jimmie Foxx Baseball Card Insert Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13546 — Joe Cronin Baseball Card Insert Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14798 — Kenley Jansen Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14910 — Luis Tiant Baseball Card Insert Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13631 — Marcelo Mayer Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13636 — Masataka Yoshida Baseball Card Rookie Insert Bosto
- Lot 13637 — Masataka Yoshida Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13644 — Michael Chavis Baseball Card Mini Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14515 — Mike Greenwell Baseball Card Rookie Boston Red So
- Lot 14590 — Mo Vaughn Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13675 — Nick Sogard Baseball Card Rookie Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14433 — Nomar Garciaparra Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14399 — Roger Clemens Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13936 — Roger Clemens Baseball Card Insert Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14814 — Roger Clemens Baseball Card Insert Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13978 — Ted Williams Baseball Card Insert Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14649 — Ted Williams Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14346 — Ted Williams Baseball Card Insert Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13986 — Tris Speaker Baseball Card Insert Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14444 — Tris Speaker Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 14236 — Tris Speaker Baseball Card Boston Red Sox
- Lot 13987 — Triston Casas Baseball Card Rookie Boston Red Sox
- … and 938 more lots
More auctions in Illinois
- Ronald Knowles Collection: Part II — Quincy · November 8, 2026
- Discovery Estate Auction Day 2 — Germantown Hills · November 8, 2026
- Coming Home: An Outstanding Fall Collection — Chicago · November 8, 2026
- Nov. 8, 2026 — Springfield · November 8, 2026
- Fall Antiques & Americana (Part 2 of 2) — DeKalb · November 8, 2026