First Pick Collectibles

Updated September 27, 2026

About First Pick Collectibles

First Pick Collectibles is an auction house based in North Canton, Ohio. Auction Hawk has listed 11 of its auctions since August 6, 2026; 1 is upcoming, with 215 lots across memorabilia & autographs, held in North Canton. Its sales run online with bidding through the house's catalog, so you can bid from anywhere.

How to bid with First Pick Collectibles

• Open an upcoming auction below for the date, location and full catalog with photos.
• Follow the catalog link to the bidding platform and register (free) before the sale.
• Bid live, leave absentee bids, or set a maximum bid; online sales close lot by lot at the listed time.
• Questions about pickup, shipping or condition: call (330)-316-8525.

Upcoming auctions (1)

• First Pick Collectibles Auction 34-003 — North Canton, Ohio · September 27, 2026

What First Pick Collectibles sells

• Memorabilia & Autographs — 192 lots in upcoming sales

Past auctions

• First Pick Collectibles Memorabilia Auction 35-02 — ended September 20, 2026
• First Pick Collectibles Auction 33-004 — ended September 17, 2026
• First Pick Collectibles Auction 32-001 — ended September 10, 2026
• First Pick Collectibles Auction 31-02 — ended September 6, 2026
• First Pick Collectibles Auction 30-03 — ended August 30, 2026
• First Pick Collectibles Auction 29-04 — ended August 27, 2026
• First Pick Sports Memorabilia Auction 28-02 — ended August 16, 2026
• First Pick Collectibles Auction 27-001 — ended August 13, 2026
• First Pick Sports Memorabilia Auction 26-003 — ended August 9, 2026
• First Pick Memorabilia Auction 25-002 — ended August 6, 2026

Other auction houses in Ohio

• GrubeAuctioneering, LLC — Fort Recovery (7 upcoming)
• WMS Auction Services — Upper Sandusky (7 upcoming)
• Steve Bolen Auctioneer — Plymouth (5 upcoming)
• Whatman Realtors & Auctioneers — Mansfield (5 upcoming)
• United Country Walton Realty & Auction Co., llc — Upper Sandusky (5 upcoming)
• Old Barn Auction — Findlay (4 upcoming)
• Richard Edwards Auctioneering — Greenville (4 upcoming)
• The Hobby Vault — Hartville (4 upcoming)

All upcoming Ohio auctions →

Frequently asked questions

Where is First Pick Collectibles located?

First Pick Collectibles is based in 4094 Kevin Street Northwest Ste A, North Canton, Ohio, 44720. Phone: (330)-316-8525.

What does First Pick Collectibles sell?

Recent catalogs from First Pick Collectibles are mostly memorabilia & autographs — 215 lots across its 1 upcoming auctions.

How do I bid with First Pick Collectibles?

Open an upcoming auction below for the date and catalog. Its sales are online: follow the catalog link, register on the bidding platform, and place bids or absentee bids before the closing time, or call (330)-316-8525 with questions.